If I were to become a trades worker I think I would have to choose becoming a construction worker. Not on roads or things like that, but to build houses. Frankly, I couldnt exactjy see myself pursuing a career in the trades but if it camedown to it this is what I would pick. As a construction worker I would be able to be outdoors and also working on homes. I really enjoy the process of creating a home, from architectural design to interior design (both careers I see as possibilities for myself).
How does the author suggest we determine the value of our work?
The author of "Shopclass as Soulcraft"suggests we measure the value of our work by usefulness. I agree with the author in many of his assertions that often times trades workers can be more useful than ultra-wealthy cubicle workers. However, I found more value in the authors concession statement that for some people, knowledge jobs are more fufilling. This leads me to believe that part of the usefulness the author is discussing is happiness, or a sense of accomplishment for the worker. Also, part of this idea of usefulness, if it is connected to happines is also connected to the happiness of others. So, like Smitty said, directing reality TV may not solve a problem or further workers' knowledge like a mechanic, there is a shread of usefulness still applicable to the dumber parts of the entertainment industry because of the happiness they bring people, whether or not it is the best form of entertainment around.
The other key message I took away from the reading was the idea of self-sufficiency. Obviously not everyone can be completely self-sufficient but the value of having multiple abilities, even if they have not been mastered, is important. If a specialized worker has some ability to use his or her hands to complete a task separate from their profession there is not only value in that because they are able to solve more everyday problems but also there is more of a connection to the world around them and more respect for people of other professions. Lastly, the more skilled workers are in the United States, or the more people that are willing to learn to have a skill, the fewer jobs will be sent overseas.
I like what you said about different people's versions of fulfillment. It made me wonder whether I would feel like I was accomplishing anything working in a knowledge-job or not.
ReplyDeleteI totally get what you mean about fulfillment coming from happiness with your job, and I really like the way you address self-sufficiency as a means of respect, both for yourself and for others. Also, the picture that's your blog background makes me happy.
ReplyDeleteI wish your last statement were true. The one about more skilled workers here meaning fewer outsourced jobs. I hope that someday it will be true, right now it is still about the financial bottom line, not the societal progress of American workers. I also enjoy your perspective on the happiness quotient. It reminds me of the axiom, "Love what you do and you will never "work" a day in your life." And yeah, self-sufficiency or self-reliance as a means of respect, BINGO. Well done!
ReplyDelete